The Chimes

“Roma” should have won Best Picture

The 91st Academy Awards left audiences and filmmakers disappointed.

Back to Article
Back to Article

“Roma” should have won Best Picture

Photo Courtesy of Signis.net

Photo Courtesy of Signis.net

Photo Courtesy of Signis.net

Jasmyne Bell, Freelance Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






(This story was originally published in print on Feb. 28, 2019).

Shock and confusion filled the Dolby Theater on Sunday night when the Academy Award for Best Picture went to “Green Book.” Spike Lee, who was also in the running for the Oscar for his BlacKkKlansman, was even seen trying to storm out of the building. The Academy does not vote based on the popularity of a film, but on what they want to communicate to Hollywood and the rest of the world about their society. If they wanted to make a statement about race, a controversial subject in the Academy in recent years, why did they choose “Green Book?”

The specific type of narrative about racism that the film explores is far over. Telling a story of reconciliation through the eyes of a white man is not only ignorant, but also writes off the voices of people of color in America. It is a band-aid solution to a much more complex topic. The implications of “Green Book” winning the most prestigious Oscar award tell the world that, according to the Academy, a film with a “we all have something to learn” message was more acceptable than that of “Roma”—which was the rightful winner of this award.

PERSONALIZED NARRATIVE

The narrative of “Roma” reflects not only Alfonso Cuarón’s childhood—the heroine, Cleo, is meant to portray of his childhood nanny—but also the political climate of Mexico in the 1970s. Earlier that night, the picture took home the Oscars for Cinematography, Foreign Film and Best Directing, the last of which Cuarón accepted minutes before losing to “Green Book.” This turn of events was equally disappointing and infuriating to many cinephiles.

“Roma” not only had breathtaking cinematography and a compelling storyline, but the lead performance from Yalitza Aparicio was superb, even more so when considering that “Roma” was Aparicio’s acting debut. In fact, the only trained actress on set was Marina de Tavira, who portrayed a reflection of Cuarón’s mother. The film’s political theme was also unique because it came from a specific time in Mexican history—something the majority of Americans probably know little about. The black and white aesthetic paired with the esoteric context of Mexican politics presented a unique depiction of a world forgotten by many, deserving more than what the Academy rewarded with.

Compared to “Green Book,” “Roma” simply stands as a much better film. Not only is it also a story that retells true events, but it also champions indigenous women. “Roma” allowed an indigenous Mexican woman to be adored and adored by audiences everywhere. Cuarón was very intentional about his depiction of women in his film. He wanted to present an ode to women who have made sacrifices and the women who continue to sacrifice everything for their families. This film checked off all the boxes for seemingly everyone—except the Academy.

BETTER STANCES ON RACISM

So, why did they fail to recognize the cinematic genius of Cuarón? The problem is not their failure to recognize it, but that in the midst of the Trump era, they wanted to make a stance using something that read, “we are not racist.” After all, “Green Book” retold a true story through the perspective of a white driver—and Don Shirley’s family was not consulted during the making of the film. With its white savior-centered premise, “Green Book” is less about engaging interracial relationships and acts more as the poster child of white guilt.

While the events in the film are not the responsibility of the vast majority of white Americans alive today, it was still not plausible for “Green Book” to snag the top prize. Furthermore, apart from “Roma,” the Academy could have also chosen other great films such as Lee’s “BlacKkKlansman” or Marvel’s “Black Panther” if they wanted to make a statement about their racial stance. The story of an Italian-American driving a black pianist through the South in the 60s did not end racism in Hollywood, but I suppose they would like to pretend it did.

3 Comments

3
Leave a Reply

2 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
1 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
3 Comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Jacob Allen

This piece is an opinion. Have you seen Green Book or the other nominees? You could make a case for every film. Green Book isn’t Dr. Don Shirley’s story, it’s Frank Vallelonga’s. The award goes to the best picture not the what makes the biggest racial stance. While I agree that Green Book isn’t my first choice to win and the Roma is the superior film, it won and people happened to like it. Historically the film to win best picture wasn’t the favorite or best choice and other films go on to stand the test of time. Roma will… Read more »

Hunter Greene

You seem to claim that Green Book is being used as a “we are not racist” statement; however, you would have preferred Roma to win with one of your own reasonings of Roma being a better film because it has an indigenous woman as a strong character. I see some hypocrisy here since you essentially claim that Green Book only won for a political move, yet saying Roma is a better choice based on a woman of a minority race being in the film. Another reason you mentioned for Roma being better than Green Book is that it is retelling… Read more »

Navigate Left
  • “Roma” should have won Best Picture

    Entertainment

    Get fired up with this Housefires playlist

  • “Roma” should have won Best Picture

    Entertainment

    Marvel’s Phase 3 stands above the rest

  • “Roma” should have won Best Picture

    Entertainment

    Flight Deck soars

  • “Roma” should have won Best Picture

    Entertainment

    “Fortnite”: The game that took the world by storm

  • “Roma” should have won Best Picture

    Entertainment

    Fever Joy calls the shots

Navigate Right
The Student News Site of Biola University
“Roma” should have won Best Picture